South-South Cooperation is a term used
to denote assistance that developing countries give to one another.
Developing countries are quick to point out, however, that this kind
of cooperation is qualitatively different from the traditional
paradigm whereby developed countries that are members of the OECD
Development Assistance Committee provide assistance to poorer nations.
Denis Degteryov, Ph.D. (Economics), Head of Department of the Theory
and History of International Relations at Peoples’ Friendship
University of Russia and Associate Professor of World Economy
at the Moscow State Institute of International Relations, talks
to us about South-South Cooperation.
— What exactly is South-South Cooperation? Why has
the United Nations decided that we need to institutionalize this kind
of cooperation?
— Traditional North-South cooperation usually involves large
countries providing assistance to their former colonies. This kind
of aid is still seen by developing countries
as paternalistic and tied to a number of obligations —
the so-called principles of «good governance».
What’s more, donor countries act as mentors for those nations that
are in receipt of aid. The countries of the «Global South»
believe that this contradicts the principle of sovereign equality for all
member nations (Article 2, Paragraph 1 of the UN Charter).
In an attempt to safeguard themselves against interference
from donor countries in their internal political and economic affairs (but
at the same time not refusing their help), recipient nations have taken
steps to promote the concept of the «right to development» and
the assurance of more equitable, preferential terms for developing
countries in international trade and other international formats.
In May 1974, the 6th Special Session of the General Assembly
of the United Nations adopted the Declaration on the Establishment
of a New International Economic Order, in Russian) and
a Programme of Action for its implementation. These resolutions
played an important role in shaping the regime of international
development assistance. Their main provisions were restated in the
preamble to the Declaration on the Right to Development
in 1986. What’s more, they were instrumental in shaping the
format of cooperation between the European Community and the African,
Caribbean and Pacific Group of States (ACP) as part of the
Second ACP-EEC Convention of Lomé in 1980–1984.
Moreover, we have been witnessing increased South-South
Cooperation between developing countries since the 1970s. Of course, such
cooperation existed earlier in the form of the
Non-Aligned Movement, the Group of 77 and the United Nations
Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD). Within the context
of the UNCTAD, which was established in 1964, the development
of international trade is clearly tied to the issue
of international aid and the economic situation of the poorest
countries. This is in stark contrast to the 1994 version
of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), which considers
the liberalization of international trade as an absolute
good.
The first United Nations Conference on Technical Cooperation among
Developing Countries was held in Buenos Aires from 30 August to 12
September 1978. The resulting Plan of Action for Promoting and
Implementing Technical Cooperation among Developing Countries signed
by the conference’s participants included 38 recommendations aimed
at achieving self-sufficiency based on mutual
cooperation in various fields.
Further development of international legislation in this sphere
is reflected in the relevant UN resolution (A/RES/49/96 dated
December 19, 1994.), which sets out the new directions for technical
cooperation among developing countries in market economy conditions
in the context of globalization. The need for developing countries
to rely on their own strengths was formalized by the United
Nations in 2002 in The New Partnership for Africa’s Development
(NEPAD).
— In what spheres is the most intensive interaction taking
place? What areas need to be developed?
— South-South Cooperation is marked by the
predominance of technical assistance and the transfer of expertise
in diverse areas of economic and scientific development. To this
end, a number of developing states have established advanced
technology centres. Countries of the «Global South» are convinced that
only they are capable of truly understanding each other’s needs and
that, consequently, only they are in a position to make
suggestions as to the best way to satisfy these needs.
South-South Cooperation differs from traditional international aid
in that assistance provided does not hinge upon the recipient country
carrying out economic or political reforms; South-South
Cooperation is at its heart a partnership between countries.
Of course, the fact that the former colonies’ place in the global
division of labour was agriculture initially hampered the development
of fully-fledged cooperation.
The first ten years after the adoption of the Buenos Aires Plan
of Action were devoted to setting up focal points and developing
the procedures for interaction. The next ten years were spent adapting the
concept of South-South Cooperation to the conditions
of the time. Expansion of trade and investment flows between the
countries of the «Global South» began during the following ten years, and
supplies of hi-tech goods and services intensified. For
example, Brazil became the world leader in ethanol fuel (bioethanol)
production technologies.
At the same time, South-South Cooperation
is developing in many different formats. Interregional cooperation
has intensified between countries in Africa and Latin America, with two
summits dedicated to the issue being held: first in Abuja, Nigeria
in 2006, which was attended by representatives of 53 African and
12 Latin American countries; then in Venezuela
in 2009 at the initiative of Hugo Chávez, where the leaders
of 49 African and 12 Latin American states were present. The choice
of venues for these summits was no accident, as Nigeria and
Venezuela are two of the most active countries
in South-South Cooperation. For example, in Nigeria, the
Nigeria Technical Cooperation Fund was set up in 2001 under the
auspices of the African Development Bank with the aim of developing
technology throughout the African continent. The Simón Bolívar Programme,
set up at the initiative of the United Nations Economic
Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean in 1993, performs
a similar function in Latin America. What’s more, Hugo Chávez
was a fervent supporter of anti-American integration
projects among the «Global South» countries, having a hand in the
formation of the «Axis of Good», the Bolivarian Alliance for the
Peoples of Our America and other initiatives.
In addition to inter-regional cooperation, the
African continent is benefiting from active cooperation with Brazil,
China, India and South Africa. It is worth noting that Brazil
is primarily developing ties with the Lusophone
(Portuguese-speaking) African countries, relying on the
«infrastructure of interaction» created by Portugal for cooperating
with its former colonies. China is also making use of the
«infrastructure of interaction» created by France for cooperation
with its former colonies. China-Africa and
Brazil-Africa summits are a regular occurrence.
We should also mention the participation of developed countries
(Japan, for example) in South-South Cooperation
on a tripartite basis. Developed countries contribute a part
of their technology and finances as a way of stimulating
relations between developing countries.
— Are any organizations besides the United Nations involved
in such initiatives?
— The United Nations remains the main platform for realizing such
initiatives (the key department here is the United Nations Office for
South-South Cooperation). In addition to UNCTAD,
we should also mention the United Nations Industrial Development
Organization (UNIDO), which was set up in 1962 and oversees the
exchange of experience and know-how in the
implementation of industrial projects.
The Group of 77 acts as a mouthpiece for the «Global South»
and is an important initiator of South-South
Cooperation. At a meeting in 2003, the Group of 77 adopted
the Marrakech Declaration, in which developed countries emphasized once
again the need, and indeed absolute necessity, of cooperating with one
another in order to move towards self-reliant
development.
It is worth noting that American experts are keeping a close
eye on the position of the «Global South» countries with regard
to South-South Cooperation, including those positions
connected with so-called Third World Approaches
to International Law (TWAIL). The first international conference
on the matter (TWAIL I) was held at Harvard Law School in 1997.
This was followed by TWAIL II, held at Osgoode Hall Law School
of York University in Ontario, Canada, in 2001; and TWAIL III,
held at Albany Law School in 2007. The most recent International
Conference on Third World Approaches to International Law (TWAIL
2011) was held at the University of Oregon Law School in October
2011. A special issue of the Indian journal Trade, Law and
Development dedicated to the topic came out that same year.
— What role does Russia play in promoting this kind
of cooperation?
— Russia sees South-South Cooperation as an important
element of the global architecture of development assistance, one
that supplements traditional forms of aid. The Council for Mutual Economic
Assistance (COMECON), led by the Soviet Union and China, acted
as an alternative source of international assistance from the
1960s to the 1980s. Immediately following the collapse of the
socialist economic system, a number of donors became significantly
stronger than others, which in many cases was led to subjective
decisions being taken about the fate of individual recipients. In the
2000s, with the emergence of new potential donors (the BRICS countries),
the architecture of international assistance became
multi-faceted once again.
Of course, the potential of Russia’s participation
in South-South Cooperation (on a tripartite basis)
has not yet been fully realized. We are talking about ambitious new
projects in the fields of professional development, natural resource
extraction, satellite communications, medicine, nuclear energy, etc.
______________________
[1] The definition of «good governance» is set out,
in particular, in the Cotonou Agreement signed between the European
Union and the African, Caribbean and Pacific Group of States in 2000
(Article 9, Paragraph 3): «In the context of a political and
institutional environment that upholds human rights, democratic principles and
the rule of law, good governance is the transparent and accountable
management of human, natural, economic and financial resources for the
purposes of equitable and sustainable development. It entails clear
decision-making procedures at the level of public
authorities, transparent and accountable institutions, the primacy of law
in the management and distribution of resources and capacity building
for elaborating and implementing measures aiming in particular
at preventing and combating corruption.»